Won't you come around again, my Sadie?
Wear your hemmed-up favorite skirt
I once thought that you could save me
But now I know you're just a flirt
I tried to tell my aunt and uncle
Which songs were true and which made up
But I could not even remember
And I honestly don't care that much
Turned a youth group boy into a vandal
Kept our minor crimes off the books
But you were more than I could handle
You taught me with the things you took
Some nights I lay awake and wonder
What was going through your head
When you kissed me in the theater
And how come you would not do it again
You surprised exactly no one
And moved to Michigan last fall
I'd like to know just how you're doing
And if you miss this place at all
You remain to me a mystery
You were a foreign way to live
I thought back then that you could save me
And now I think maybe you did