I'm a secret keeper
For every guy I've known
To me they're everything
To them I'm just a body
And in the light you paint me
I'm feeling awfully dim
But I don't know when I'll kiss again
So I'll ride this to the end
I'm a secret keeper
For every guy in my bed
Half of them know they'll never call again
The others hope I can save them
From their minds
From their little lies
On a saturday morning
I can hear your breath
Can't resist one last glance
Before you shut down our plans
You hold me by my waistline
And in your eyes, I see fault
I hear the words before they leave your mouth
It's been nice, but it's over now
I'm a secret keeper
For every guy in my bed
Half of them know they'll never call again
The others hope I can save them
From their minds
From their little lies
Bury knives under floorboards
Just to use when you get bored
You are no longer my warmth
Make sure our story gets burned
Erase all those good times
And regret all the white lies
I believed when you told me
You would never let go
Let go
I'm a secret keeper
For every guy I've known
Thought maybe he would want to stay this time
Or hold my hand as he made me cry
All these years
Choking on tears